Beginner’s Guide: Antivirus vs EDR for Startups & SMBs

Ethan Hays
7min

The Changing Face of Cybersecurity for Small Businesses

If you're running a small or medium-sized business today, cybersecurity might not be keeping you up at night. But maybe it should. 

While you're focused on cash flow, growth and serving customers, cybercriminals are turning more and more of their attention to businesses just like yours.

Cyber attacks against SMBs have surged 200% in recent years. Why? 

Because cybercriminals see SMBs as "low-hanging fruit”. SMBs are soft targets with valuable data and often without sophisticated defenses.

Think about it. If you’re a criminal who wants to pull off a heist, is it easier to attack Fort Knox or the local convenience store? 

Your business is the cybersecurity equivalent of the local convenience store. Bad actors are looking at your business as a target of opportunity at any hour of the day or night. 

It doesn’t feel good to think about this, so most business owners don’t. And the results are devastating:

  • 43% of all cyber attacks now target SMBs
  • 51% of SMBs have no cybersecurity measures in place at all
  • 60% of small businesses close their doors within six months of a significant breach

As these threats evolve, your defenses must evolve, too. 

You've probably heard of antivirus software, because it’s been the standard recommendation for decades. 

But in today's threat landscape, cybersecurity professionals are focused on new technologies called Endpoint Detection and Response, or EDR. 

Understanding the difference between these two approaches could be crucial for your business's survival.

Understanding the Basics: What Are We Actually Talking About?


Traditional Antivirus: The Security Guard Who Checks IDs

Traditional antivirus is like a security guard who stands at your door with a list of known troublemakers. When someone approaches, the guard checks their ID against the list. If there's a match, they're denied entry. If not, they get to walk right in.

This approach has worked for decades because it's straightforward and effective against known threats. Your antivirus software maintains a database of malware "signatures". These are the fingerprints of known viruses and malicious files. When you run a scan, the software checks your files against this database.

Antivirus typically works by:

  • Scanning files when they're accessed or on a regular schedule
  • Comparing what it finds against a database of known threats
  • Quarantining or deleting anything that matches a known threat
  • Occasionally using basic behavioral analysis to spot suspicious activity


Antivirus is a tried-and-true method that has protected millions of computers over the last 30 years. 

But there's a fundamental flaw: it can only stop threats it already knows about.

EDR: The Smart Security System That Watches Behavior

Now imagine replacing that security guard with an advanced security system that doesn't just check IDs but monitors everyone's behavior once they're inside. It notices patterns and can respond immediately:

  • who's going where
  • what they're touching
  • whether they're acting suspiciously


That's essentially what EDR does. Rather than just checking files against a database, EDR continuously monitors the activities occurring on your devices (endpoints) in real-time. It's watching processes, connections, and user behaviors to identify suspicious patterns that might indicate a breach. 

For example, let’s say your EDR detects a big surge in file encryption. This is much more likely to be a ransomware attack than a security-conscious employee protecting a huge number of files. EDR detects this behavior immediately and blocks it.

EDR works by:

  • Continuously monitoring all activity on devices in real-time
  • Using advanced analytics to identify suspicious behaviors
  • Providing detailed visibility into what's happening across your network
  • Automatically responding to potential threats as they emerge
  • Collecting forensic data that helps understand how an attack happened

This approach is particularly powerful because it can detect new, never-before-seen threats based purely on suspicious behavior, not just known signatures. 

Why the Difference Matters: Real-World Implications

The distinction between these approaches isn't just technical. It has real-world implications for your business's security.

The Detection Gap: Finding What You Don't Know to Look For

Here's a startling statistic: the average time for a business to discover they've been attacked and breached is 194 days.

 

That's more than 6 months for attackers to be inside your systems, stealing your data, planting backdoors, or preparing for a devastating ransomware attack.

Doesn’t 194 days seem like an insanely long amount of time? Why does it take so long? 

Because traditional antivirus can't detect what it doesn't know to look for.

Modern cyber attacks often don't use conventional malware that leaves files on your system. Instead, they might exploit legitimate tools already on your computer, use fileless malware that exists only in memory, or employ zero-day exploits (attacks that exploit previously unknown vulnerabilities, or have never been seen before).

This is where EDR shines. By monitoring actual behaviors rather than just checking files, EDR spots the unusual patterns that indicate an attack is underway, even if the specific attack has never been seen before.

This makes EDR especially valuable today, when the variety and velocity of threats is growing exponentially due to attackers’ use of AI. When AI is being used offensively against you, you need to use AI defensively to protect your business.

The Response Speed: Minutes vs. Months

When a breach occurs, time is your enemy. The longer an attacker has access to your systems, the more damage they can do.

Traditional antivirus might eventually detect and quarantine malware, but it typically doesn't provide much insight into what happened before or after the detection. If the attack used techniques that evaded detection, you might never know you were compromised.

EDR is designed for rapid detection and response:

  • It can automatically isolate infected devices from your network
  • It provides detailed information about how the attack happened
  • It helps identify what systems were affected and what data might have been compromised
  • It enables much faster recovery and remediation

For a small business, this difference can be existential. Detecting and stopping an attack in minutes rather than months could mean the difference between a minor incident and closing your doors for good.

Choosing What's Right for Your Business

So should you abandon antivirus and go all-in on EDR? The answer depends on your specific situation.

When Antivirus Makes Sense

Traditional antivirus still has its place, particularly in these scenarios:

  • Low-risk operations: Businesses that do not handle sensitive customer data (PII) or valuable intellectual property may have lower security requirements
  • Supplementary protection: Antivirus can work alongside other security measures as part of a layered defense

For many home users and very small businesses that don’t handle sensitive data, a good antivirus solution might be sufficient. It's better than having no protection at all, but not much.

When EDR Becomes Essential

EDR becomes increasingly important as your business grows. The longer you’re in business and the most successfully you become, the more sophisticated threats you’ll face:

  • You handle sensitive data: If you store customer information (PII), financial data, or other sensitive information, you need stronger protection
  • You operate in a regulated industry: Healthcare, financial services, and other regulated industries often have specific security requirements that antivirus alone can't meet
  • You're a target: Some industries and geographies face higher rates of attack and need more sophisticated defenses
  • You can't afford downtime: If your business operations would be severely impacted by a security incident, the additional protection of EDR is worth the investment
  • You have remote workers: With employees working from anywhere, the traditional “security perimeter” of office work has dissolved, making endpoint protection more critical

For many SMBs, EDR has moved from being a luxury to a necessity. The question is no longer whether you need this level of protection, but how to implement it effectively.

Overcoming the Barriers to Modern Security

Historically, EDR solutions were expensive and hard to configure, putting them out of reach for most SMBs.

The Cost Challenge

Enterprise EDR solutions were often priced for large corporations with extensive security budgets. For many small businesses, the cost seemed prohibitive compared to simple antivirus software.

However, the security landscape is changing. 

As EDR technology has matured, more affordable options have emerged specifically designed for small and medium businesses. Some providers now offer EDR protection at price points competitive with premium antivirus solutions. 

For example, Cybee offers enterprise-grade EDR with advanced AI capabilities for free, forever. So there’s no reason not to give your business the protection it deserves.

When evaluating costs, it's also important to consider the potential financial impact of a breach. With the average cost of a data breach now exceeding $150,000 for small businesses, security measures are a good investment.

The Complexity Challenge

Another traditional barrier has been complexity. Early EDR solutions required dedicated security teams to deploy, monitor, and manage them effectively. The systems generated large volumes of alerts that needed expert analysis, making them impractical for businesses without IT security specialists.

Newer EDR solutions have addressed this challenge with:

  • Simplified deployment and management
  • Automated analysis and response capabilities
  • Cloud-based management that reduces infrastructure requirements
  • Options that provide expert oversight via managed services or AI

For example, Cybee is designed specifically for SMBs without IT teams. You can set up security for every device your employees use in under 5 minutes. And our AI chat is like a CISO (Chief Information Security Officer) in your pocket. You can ask direct questions about what’s happening inside your network at any hour of the day or night and get an answer in plain language you can understand.

These advancements have made enterprise-grade security more accessible to SMBs.

Looking Forward: The Evolving Security Landscape

As you consider your security options, it's worth understanding where the industry is heading. The future likely belongs to comprehensive security platforms that combine multiple protection technologies:

  • Extended Detection and Response (XDR) expands protection beyond endpoints (EDR) to include networks, cloud workloads, and email to safeguard your whole business
    • The SME and Enterprise versions of Cybee are full XDR: 
      • enterprise-grade EDR with advanced AI capabilities
      • control of your entire business network (all devices & cloud services)
      • visibility into all devices consuming your business’s data, including files in SaaS systems like Google Workspace, Office 365, Slack, GitHub, etc
      • 1-click device hardening and remediation to cybersecurity industry benchmarks 
      • 1-click audit-ready reports generated for 27 regulatory regimes including GDPR, HIPAA, SOC 2, DORA and more
  • Managed Detection and Response (MDR) combines advanced security tools with human expertise to provide comprehensive protection as a service, although with a higher price tag that makes it inaccessible for many SMBs

Making Your Decision: Practical Next Steps

If you're a small business owner trying to navigate these complex choices, here are some practical steps to consider:

  1. Assess your risk profile: Consider what sensitive data you handle, what regulations you must comply with, and how attractive a target you might be to attackers

  2. Evaluate your current protections: Understand what security measures you already have in place and where gaps might exist

  3. Consider your resources: Be realistic about your budget and your ability to manage security tools

  4. Solutions designed for your business size: Look for EDR & XDR specifically tailored to small and medium businesses without IT teams

The Bottom Line: Security as a Business Essential


In today's digital business environment, cybersecurity isn't an IT issue. It's a business survival issue. 


The question is what level of protection is appropriate for your specific situation.


Traditional antivirus software still has value, but the rising sophistication of cyber threats means many businesses need the advanced capabilities that EDR provides.


By understanding the differences between these approaches and carefully evaluating your needs, you can make informed decisions that protect your business without breaking your budget or overwhelming your team.


Remember: the cost of good security is way less than the cost of a breach. In cybersecurity, as in many areas of business and life, an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.

Enterprise-Grade Cybersecurity & Compliance for SMEs
Get world-class EDR, cloud security, and compliance automation in one platform.No technical expertise required.
Learn more about Cybee

Heading

This is some text inside of a div block.
This is some text inside of a div block.